All Division 3
| Allegheny College | Marietta College |
| Augsburg College | Milligan College |
| Averett University | Millsaps College |
| Birmingham Southern | Moravian College |
| Bluffton University | Mount Union University |
| Capital University | Muskingum University |
| Case Western University | Occidental College |
| College of Wooster | Ohio Wesleyan |
| Concordia University (MN) | Puget Sound |
| Eastern Connecticut St. | Rowan University |
| Eastern University | Rutgers - Camden |
| Franklin & Marshall | St. John's University |
| Frostburg State University | St. Mary's University |
| Geneva College | St. Thomas University |
| Guilford College | Thiel College |
| Gustavus Adolphus College | Trinity College of Hartford |
| Hamline University | Trinity University |
| Heidelburg University | Washington Adventist University |
| John Carroll University | Washington and Jefferson College |
| Kean University | Wesley College |
| Kenyon College | Whittier College |
| Lake Erie College | Willamette University |
| Lynchburg College | Wisconsin Oshkosh |
| Marian University Baseball |
